Our Menu

Get Shucky!

Fresh Oysters on the Half Shell

Ameripure Oysters shucked by your favorite bartender and served ice cold with cocktail, horseradish, crackers, and a lemon.

Fresh Shucked Clams

Juicy Middleneck Clams put under the knife and cracked right in front of you by our staff.

The App Shack

South Florida Smoked Fish Dip

Smoked mullet, marlin, and sailfish. A traditional Southwest Florida dish.

Loaded Tots

Lots of tots, ranch, cheese, and scallions with a bunch of crunch.

Macho Nachos

With all the fixins'.

Coconut Shrimp

7 jumbo coconut battered shrimp topped with our homemade pineapple salsa and served with a sweet glaze chili sauce.

Potstickers

6 plump dumplings filled with Asian spiced pork served with a teriyaki dipping sauce.

Southwest Eggrolls

Crunchy egg rolls filled with smoked chicken, black beans, corn, red peppers, spinach, pepper jack cheese blend and a side of salsa.

Pretzel Bites

Freshly baked warm salted soft pretzels. Served with cinnamon sugar butter or a side of melted cheese.

Mac-N-Cheese Bites

Fried little nuggets of yumminess served with a side of ranch.

Mozzarella Cheese Sticks

Crispy on the outside, gooey on the inside with homemade marinara sauce for dipping.

Fried Calamari

A healthy portion of lightly fried rings and tenticles served with homemade marinara sauce.

Onion Ring Basket

Thick cut gourmet breaded Spanish sweet onion rings.

Cheese Fries

Smothered with applewood smoked bacon, monterey jack cheese, and scallions.

Crab Balls

8 lump crab stuffed balls fried and served with homemade dill sauce.

Chicken Balls

Tender chunks of chicken breast meat with spicy seasoned breadding with a side of BBQ sauce.

Just Wing It

Rusty's Classic Chicken Wings

10 fresh plump chicken wings deep fried and tossed in your choice of our delicious sauces.

The Rusty Pail

50 Jumbo Chicken Wings shaken not stirred, in your choice of sauce. Served with plenty of blue cheese and celery to go around.

Boneless Chicken Wings

Four tender strips of chicken breast breaded, fried, sauced, and served with blue cheese and celery.

Choose One Of Our Amazing Wing Sauces:

Off the Hook

Fish & Chips

Beer battered in all the right places. this haddock special has been a top seller for years.

Crab Cake Platter

Lump crab cakes fried to perfection with rice, steamed broccoli, and coleslaw.

Crab Cake Sandwich

Lump crab cakes fried to perfection served on a kaiser roll with homemade tartar and coleslaw.

Boom Boom Shrimp

8 lightly breaded shrimp fried golden brown and glazed once over with our signature boom boom sauce or another of our wing sauces.

Crunchy Grouper Sandwich

This is a delicacy in the fried fish world. Yummy grouper on a fresh kaiser with fries and coleslaw.

Grouper Reuben

Our fresh daily grouper fingers fried with coleslaw, swiss cheese, 1000 island dressing on grilled rye bread.

Catch of the Day

Ask your bartender what came off the boat today.

Fresh Grouper Sandwich

Handcut fresh daily filet of grouper. served blackened, grilled, or lightly fried in our signature breading. served on a fresh kaiser roll with a side of coleslaw and french fries.

Grouper Platter

Filet of grouper grilled to perfection with rice and steamed broccoli. Served either blackened, Jamaican jerk, or mesquite style.

Haddock Sandwich

Hand cut fresh everyday, blackened, grilled, or lightly fried on a fresh brioche bun with coleslaw and fries.

Crunchy Grouper Basket

This is a delicacy in the fried fish world. Yummy grouper on a fresh brioche with coleslaw and fries.

Fried Oyster Basket

A healthy portion of extra select oysters fried in our secret breading. Served with fried and coleslaw.

Fried Shrimp Basket

A fresh plump shrimp battered in our house recipe. served with fried and coleslaw.

From the Steampot

Middleneck Clams

Steamed to perfection with a touch of old bay and drawn butter for dipping.

Peel & Eat Shrimp

Marinated in our secret blend of herbs and spices. Served hot or cold with cocktail sauce and lemon.

Rusty's Traditional Favorites

Beans & Rice

This is a very secret recipe that we have had for over 19 years, once you try it you will be hooked. Served with garlic bread. Add grilled chicken or fresh catch for an extra charge.

Chicken Burrito

Juicy chicken thigh meat slow simmered in corona, wrapped up and piled high with our homemade black bean salsa, sour cream, and jack cheese.

Cowabunga Chimichanga

2 of our delicious burritos fried to perfection and topped with salsa, sour cream, and shredded jack cheese.

Chicken Finger Basket

Fried tender strips of chicken served with honey mustard and crispy fries.

Mahi Tacos

Blackened mahi mahi wrapped in warm flower tortillas with crisp lettuce, tomatoes, and pineapple salsa. Served with a side of beans and rice.

Drunken Mussles

Our famous drunken mussles. Available as an appetizer or entree.

Slider City

Mini Burgers

Three homemade burgers on grilled rolls with your choice of cheese.

Mini BLT's

Applewood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo on toasted mini buns.

Slider Trio

A delicious sampling of our mini menu: one crab cake slider, one BLT slider, and one mini burger slider.

Crab Cake Slider

3 plump crab cake patties on mini bunz.

Buffalo Chicken Slider

Toss em’ in your favorite sauce and topped with lettuce, tomato and blue cheese.

Burgers Nation

All Rusty’s burgers are cattleman selected 1/2 lb lean angus beef and chargrilled to your liking with choice of cheese: American, Cheddar, Swiss, White American, Bleu Cheese, Provolone, or Pepper Jack.

Classic Cheeseburger

Your traditional cheeseburger with your choice of cheese.

Southwest Burger

It’s what the cowboys eat. Savory sautéed onions, BBQ, Applewood smoked bacon, jalapeños and melted cheddar cheese on garlic bread.

Mushroom Swiss Burger

Of course sautéed mushrooms and melted Swiss.

Applewood Burger

Smoked bacon cheeseburger with your choice of cheese.

Bacon Bleu Burger

On a fresh Brioche with blue cheese dressing, Applewood smoked bacon and melted blue cheese crumbles.

Patty Melt

Grilled onion, Swiss cheese and 1000 Island dressing on grilled marble rye.

Rusty's Good Morning Burger

1/2 lb. burger topped with Applewood smoked bacon, fried egg and American cheese.

Sandwiches

All sandwiches are served with a complimentary side. Make it a wrap for $1 upcharge.

Chicken Sandwich

Our 7 oz. chicken breast served on a fresh Brioche bun, prepared your way: Crunchy, Grilled, or Buffalo Blackened Applewood Smoked Bacon (add $1).

Turkey Club Sandwich

Smoked turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and ranch piled high on Texas toast.

Grandpa Bob's Pork Tenderloin

Huge wagon wheel sized pork tenderloin taken down to pound town and served on a Brioche with horseradish mayo.

Rusty's Philly Cheesesteak

Meaty, gooey, and delightfully messy. Peppers, onion, choice of cheese on a fresh hoagie roll.

Tuna Salad Sandwich

Our homemade tuna salad piled high on marble rye and drug through the garden with a healthy portion of home style fries.

Tuna Melt

Our homemade tuna salad with melted cheddar on grilled marble rye.

Turkey Rueben

In this reinvented classic, turkey takes a rightful place between melted cheese and marble rye bread, with homemade coleslaw and 1000 island dressing.

Salads

Make it a wrap for $1 upcharge.

Classic Caesar

Crisp romaine, croutons, and parmesan cheese all tossed in our creamy caesar dressing. Add chicken or fresh fish.

Taco Salad

Fresh crispy tortilla bowl piled high with beef taco meat, jack cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, red onion, jalapenos, sour cream and salsa.

Santa Fe Chicken Salad

Chopped romaine tossed in ranch, topped with bbq chicken, jack cheese, black bean salsa, tomatoes, red onion, and crispy tortilla chips.

Crunchy Chicken Salad

Our secret crunchy chicken is a staple around these parts with honey mustard, romaine lettuce, tomatoes, red onion, Monterey jack cheese and croutons.

Rusty's Cobb Salad

Fresh cut romaine lettuce with rows of tomato, bacon, egg, onion, cheese, corn, and croutons with your choice of dressing. Add any protein.

Soups

Grandma Rita's Conch Chowder

The most authentic chowder from Lee's Best to Key West.

Boston Clam Chowder

A creamy crowd favorite with lots of potatoes and clams, sprinkled with bacon and green onion.

Gronk Chowder

A delicious mixture of conch and clam chowder.

Homemade Chili

Meaty chili loaded with beef and beans, topped with onions and cheese.